People’s Choice: Best Island Take Out

People’s Choice: Best Island Take Out

Last week’s Instagram Stories Poll was for Best Island Take Out!

As take out has become incredibly popular when you’re not in the mood or have the time to cook, we asked locals to chime in and vote for their favorite take out on Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard.

Also commonly referred to as:
carry out

Mouth-watering voting ensued… on each island we tallied the top 4 and this is what you came up with:

Nantucket’s Top Four Take Out: Millie’s, Stubby’s, Fresh, Steamboat Pizza

Martha’s Vineyard Top Four Take Out: Giardano’s, Wharf Pub, Nat’s Nook, Waterside Market

After great participation from YOU, we had two final contenders for each island:
Nantucket: Millie’s versus Stubby’s
Martha’s Vineyard: Giardano’s versus Wharf Pub


The Best Island Take Out as voted by the people, for the people are:

Millie’s is located 6 miles from where we dock downtown. With an eclectic menu ranging from seafood to tacos and quesadillas to po boys, Millie’s has something to excite every palate. While they are voted best take out, they now offer outdoor dining! If you’re up for the outside dining, we highly recommend a Madaket Mystery 😉

Wharf Pub is located in Edgartown, about 6 miles from where we dock in Oak Bluffs. Open for lunch, dinner and drinks to go, the Wharf Pub is serving delicious choices in small plates, fresh and fried seafood, burgers, sandwiches, steak and lobster. Classic pub food and a local’s favorite!

Follow us on Instagram to vote in our latest poll!

Leave a Reply

Where would you like to go?

1 adult
1 adult

Passenger Details